Sunday, October 9, 2016

Out With The Old, and In With The...New?

I am pretty sure that my co-workers are getting sick of me saying “let me tell you what I learned in class this week.” So, this past week, when I was organizing my materials for class, one of them, saw the book assignment,  The Victorian Internet, “That sure looks interesting,” she said sarcastically.


As I went home that night, I wasn’t sure what to expect. As I began reading it, I soon found out that it was going to be very hard to put the book down.  Author Tom Standage, took us on the journey on the invention of the telegraph.  What Mr. Standage also did was show us a case study of what happens when new technology is introduced to the world. While the technology of the telegraph may seem outdated, if it weren't for that invention, almost 180 years ago, we would not have interconnectedness that we have come to know and love today.


Before we dive too far into this book and what I learned, first I want to talk about the word technology. Technology does not just mean the newest electronic gadget.


Technology is a technique for mediating between you and the world.
Many generalizations can be made after reading,  The Victorian Internet,  however, three stuck out to me.


  1. Technology is invented to solve problems- saying that technology is designed to address a problem, I think is an understatement. Starting with the telegraph being invented to speed up communication through, all they through text messaging today. New technology has been developed to make communication faster and faster. However, after new technology is invented is starts to create other problems. It creates new avenues for criminal activity, skepticism, and misuse.


  1. Technology has a predictable pattern of diffusion- When new technology is invented, it follows a predictable pattern. When a new technology is introduced it starts out by being available to a select few, mainly the inventors. Then it moves into the gimmick phase, as it begins to attract attention, and more and more people start to buy into it. The gimmick is the phase that takes the longest to move through, and sometimes a technology never gets past the gimmick stage.


  1. Technology creates new techniques to expand interconnectedness- Never before has the world seemed so small. That is thanks in large part to technology. New technology has allowed us to share knowledge between countries, and cultures. Technology has had a great on the globalization of the world that we live in today.

While many other things can be learned from The Victorian Internet, these three generalizations proved to be the most meaningful for me. While technology is amazing and is created with good intentions, it is almost never designed with education in mind. As teachers, our job is to find ways to use the new technologies and apply them to our educational world. That is sometimes easier said than done, but I am up to that challenge. After all, just having the computers in classrooms is not enough. Making them useful for the students so they can apply the skills they learn to their everyday lives. After all, just putting them on a computer just makes it another gimmick, and after all, another gimmick is the last thing teachers need in their classrooms.

5 comments:

  1. Nick... I find your gimmick comment very pertinent. There have been several times that I start to use a new program in the classroom, only to find out it isn't what I thought it was. It has sometimes been difficult to determine the usefulness until I get it in my students' hands. For instance, I thought Frontrowed was really awesome until my students were watching the helpful video lessons embedded in the program designed to help them progress. The students only became more frustrated. It was also more aligned to the common core standards which were not applicable for us. I had to abandon that one!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that trying to find technology that fits what I want to do is always a challenge. Most of the things that I want to try seem to connect with the Common Core Standards and not the VDOE SOL's. After this past week I have realized that these technologies don't create an affordance. I need to use what we learned to take a closer look at the technologies that I either currently use, or want to use, and see if their affordances out way the consequences. Especially

      Delete
  2. I feel like teachers are definitely a group that gets overwhelmed with an overabundance of technology--some gimmicky, or just not effective for teaching curtain content. Like we learned in class, technology isn't great just because it's technology. It has to create an affordance--actually help students with the content that is being taught or practiced. It's easy to fall for "cool" technology before we really think about how useful it is to our students' progress. I think about all the times I've been to conferences and seen something that my students just HAD TO have. It's great that technology gets our minds churning with great ideas, but it's also important to take that step back. We've all fallen for the throw an iPad or something into the lesson because, hey, it's technology and the students are using it! Learning about affordances really made me take a step back and think about how I've implemented certain technology when it probably wasn't the best kind to use.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sometimes it is so hard to find the right technologies, and it can be so tough to be tempted by that new gimmick. I remember being at VSTE last year, and I saw all these cool things that other teachers were using, but I struggled so much to see how it could be used in my own classroom. Sure, we could use it for this part of X unit, but with the constraints in budgets is there other tech that could be used more frequently that provides the same affordances?

    ReplyDelete
  4. So true that technology is rarely invented for education. AND, even when the technology is designed for education...I feel like real teachers were never really consulted on how to make it the best it can be to fit into a real classroom setting. All of this creates a tricky situation for us as educators to have to be well versed and creative so we can implement these tools effectively and with purpose.

    ReplyDelete