Monday, September 26, 2016

Knowledge is Power

This week in class we began talking about the third design principle, knowledge. As teachers, we are always striving to impart knowledge on our students. The question though is, what kind of knowledge do we want them to have?  In the current classroom model, the goal seems to be content knowledge. In other words, teaching children as much information as we can. While content knowledge is important to our student's lives, content knowledge alone is not enough. Having students constantly taking tests is only teaching students to do well in school, it is not teaching them to do well in life. This is why genuine learning is not currently happening in schools.
This week I read an article titled,  Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning (Brown, Collins, and Duguid, 1989). This article began to show the importance of acquiring true knowledge in the classroom.  In order to understand the article, you first had to understand the title.
Situated + Cognition = located + brain activity
When you separate the two, knowledge becomes inert, and like inert gasses, the knowledge just sits there, not being used.
So how can this be fixed?
The authors spoke heavily about enculturation - the task of bringing students into the culture of what it is they are learning. The outcome of this, is that students think, feel, and act as if they are readers, writers, chemists, biologists, or historians. This method of teaching allows students to become active participants in their own learning, rather than passive participants. Content learning is essential for students, but it has a specific place. Content is a means of getting to the conceptual end.
How can it be done, though?
I invite you into the culture of cognitive mentorship.  It is the difference between teaching students the differences between series and parallel circuits, and creating a classroom power outage and having the students determine and create a circuit that would get the lights back on.
Students should be doing what Drs. Priscilla Norton and Karin Wiberg call “The ABCS of Activity”:
Authentic Activity- inviting the students in the culture of learning, and making it meaningful for them.
Building Knowledge-  reading articles, lectures, reading textbooks, worksheets. While the activities should be authentic for the students, they need the background information in order to make it successful.
Constructing Activities- the mentors construct the problems for the students to solve.
Sharing Activities- giving the students the opportunities to share what they created.
Another concept from Drs. Norton and Wiberg is knowledge of Structure, Process, and Discourse with Content as Vehicle:
Structures- are the nouns, theories or generalizations of a lesson.
Process- is the ways that they come together
Discourse- are the organizational communication patterns for the community and culture.
Understanding the SPD, and the ABCS of Design Process will help me implement Drs. Norton and Wiberg's 3rd piece of advice, the AeCTS lesson design process. This is a strategy I am looking forward to utilizing in my own classroom, as it will make learning more meaningful and authentic for my students.  The process is as follows:
Authentic problem- giving the students a real problem that needs an answer, a problem that they can connect to.
exit strategy- tieing up the end of the activity. This needs to be planned out at the beginning so you are not scrambling at the end to bring closure for your students.
Clear outcome- Something that needs to be produced at the end.
Thinking skills- teaching the skills needed for that activity.
Software skills- teaching only what is needed for the task at hand. Students do not need to know everything that PowerPoint can do if they are are only asked to create slides and add a picture.
As teachers we are cognitive mentors, and that means that our students are our cognitive apprentices. As cognitive mentors, we must take on a facilitating role in the classroom,  allowing our apprentices to take charge of their own learning, while we coach them along the way.  Teaching doesn’t need to be done from the front of the classroom, it can also be done on the sidelines.

Monday, September 19, 2016

The Saber-Toothed Curriculum

Growing up I was always taught to never judge a book by its cover. My copy of The Saber-Toothed Curriculum  was old and worn down, and start to fall apart as I was opened it. So, naturally I instantly thought that this book was going to be so antiquated, there is no possible way I would learn anything from it. Then seeing that it was published in 1939, I became even more convinced of how useless the information would be. But none the less, I read it anyway and I was very wrong about claiming it would be useless.


After reading the first chapter, Seminar in Tijuana,  I became fully engrossed in the book. In this chapter, we learn of Dr. Peddiwell the alleged professor of Petaluma State University, and Raymond Wayne a former student of Dr. Peddiwell. Dr. Peddiwell discusses the bar. At which they are standing. The bar claims to be the longest in the world, and Dr. Peddiwell wants to see the proof. This sparks a series of lectures from Dr. Peddiwell, the fictitious author, doctor and professor on the decline of the education system. Dr. Peddiwell, as a decline theorist, describes in no uncertain terms the devastating consequences of an education system that does evolve,


In The Saber-Toothed Curriculum, Dr. Peddiwell speaks allegorically of the failure of an educational system. In my previous entry, I discussed the first design principle, teachers as designers. This story was an example of a poorly designed educational system. The community “elders” were always wanting the teachers to teach the skills of tiger-scaring, fish grabbing, and horse-clubbing, long after those skills were no longer necessary to learn. Learning these skills eventually, lead an unsuccessful community.  Due to the pride of the community and the obsession over tradition.


The story runs parallel to our educational system today. Why are we still teaching students how to multiply, and how to memorize useless facts. We live in a world now where the memorization of facts, will not get you very far. We need to be educating our students to think. Most importantly about the second design principle, the ends principle. Thinking with the end in mind. Teaching them that in order to be successful they need to envision the end product, and develop a way to achieve it.


The educational system created by New-Fist did not do this. Even after the young of the community came to elders, and explaining what they could do to help. What did the elders do? They were sent away, to play with rocks. This community was eventually was conquered and failed. They did not spend time thinking about their futures, or educating people to be warriors to protect them, so when the enemy came they were wiped out.


The main lesson from this book comes down to training vs. educating, and deciding what was better. Training people do do jobs or learn information that they will not actually need to use or educating them to be upstanding citizens, teaching them how to work, how to think for themselves, how to work with other people to be successful, and teaching them that failure is okay, as long as you don’t give up. So training or educating, which is better? To use an example from my professor, Dr. Priscilla Norton, “just put the word sex in front of both. Sex education or sex training, which would you want your child to have.” I think we can all agree there is only one right answer.

Don’t you think?

Friday, September 9, 2016

Teachers are Designers!

Teachers are many things, professionals, nurturers, planners and educators and  with that comes that added responsibility of training today’s youth how to be successful in their futures for jobs, many of which are not created yet. I love my job. Teaching is as much an art form as it is anything else. For centuries in my field we have to find the perfect balance of using our content knowledge, and pedagogical knowledge in order to plan lessons to effectively teach our students.  The world has changed drastically since this model first was adapted. Why hasn’t education adapted too? Students are now coming to us with a wealth of technological skills, that should be used in classrooms to help them advance through their curriculum.  Now not only should teachers be balancing their content knowledge and their pedagogical knowledge, they also have to balance those with their technological knowledge. Doing this, involves changing the mindset of the teaching profession. No longer can we as educators  be focused on simply planning lessons to deliver and educate our students with content. Teachers now have to become designers.

Design is “the human power of conceiving, planning, and making products [and systems] that serve human beings [and learners] in the accomplishment of their individual and collective purposes” (Buchanan, 2001, p. 191).

You may ask, “What’s the difference between designing a lesson and planning a lesson?” Take two examples from articles that I have recently read. In “Glued to the screen: A third-grade class where kids spend 75% of the day on iPads” Author Gail Robinson talked about third graders in Morgan Mercaldi’s class.  The article talks about how these students are using their technological skills to enhance their learning. Ms. Mercaldi has done an amazing job of bringing technology into the classroom.

Now, let’s look at another classroom in the article “Inspired By Serial, Teens Create Podcasts As A Final Exam,”  author Linda Flanagan tells us about teacher Alexa Schlechter, a 10th grade English teacher.  Ms. Schlechter  realized that a 2-hour sit-down final was pointless for her students and was an inaccurate gauge of their knowledge. (Flanagan, 2015)  So Ms. Schechter decided instead of a final to have her students create podcasts to show their knowledge.

Both of these teachers used technology, so what’s the difference?  Ms. Mercaldi in the first lesson successfully planned lessons that incorporated technology.  However, Ms. Schlechter in the second article noticed a problem in her classroom, then designed a solution for her problem. The second is what we as teachers should be aiming for.

I am fortunate enough to be in a school with a one-to-one ratio of computers to all students. Now being in the 4th year of this program I have now realized I am not using technology in the way that I envisioned myself. I have been using the technology as a tool in planning and implementing my lesson. Ms. Schlechter and her podcast final have started to inspire me to start to look for problems in my own classroom and grade level to design solutions for. As a teacher, I am many things a professional, nurturer, a planner, an educator, and now I want to be a designer as well.